Best Of

Best First Cars

Discover the ideal first cars for new drivers, ranging from Audi to Tesla, prioritizing safety, reliability, and affordability.

Read time

11 minutes

Date

12.07.2023

Share

Your first set of wheels. For many young drivers, those car keys represent freedom, excitement, and a rite of passage into adulthood. But with this new freedom comes big decisions. What features does this inaugural set of wheels need for safety, reliability, and functionality within budget? Whether you're interested in a compact hatchback, a spacious SUV, or a sleek sedan, there are plenty of options for you to choose from. The following list can hopefully guide you in making a decision.


If you're not quite ready to commit to buying a car outright, you might want to consider a car subscription service like FINN. With FINN, you can enjoy the flexibility of driving a car without the long-term commitment or hidden fees associated with car ownership.

7 best first cars

Price is a factor when choosing your first car, but it shouldn’t be the only factor, or it may come back to bite you. No new driver wants a car that’s constantly in for repairs, so look out for reliability. And, as a new driver, you’re more susceptible than most to accidents, so safety features are also very important.


Take a look at the following best first cars for new drivers.

1. Audi A3 Sedan

  • Average price: $35,400
  • Body style: Sedan
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good (2022 Top Safety Pick+)


The Audi A3 Sedan proves luxury can meet practicality. Understated style wraps a potent 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine, so you get sports car acceleration with boardroom refinement. Yet the A3 looks out for you thanks to smart driver assists spotting hazards you might miss. Inside, sink into quality materials and ergonomic comfort reminiscent of pricier Audis. Factor in excellent fuel economy, and the A3 reshapes expectations for the compact luxury class. Starting around $35,400, it blends performance with sophistication at a competitive value. For those wanting four-door practicality without sacrificing excitement, the A3 warrants a close look.

  • Good gas mileage
  • Advanced features
  • Premium interior 
buick envision
buick envision

1. Audi A3 Sedan

  • Average price: $35,400
  • Body style: Sedan
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good (2022 Top Safety Pick+)


The Audi A3 Sedan proves luxury can meet practicality. Understated style wraps a potent 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine, so you get sports car acceleration with boardroom refinement. Yet the A3 looks out for you thanks to smart driver assists spotting hazards you might miss. Inside, sink into quality materials and ergonomic comfort reminiscent of pricier Audis. Factor in excellent fuel economy, and the A3 reshapes expectations for the compact luxury class. Starting around $35,400, it blends performance with sophistication at a competitive value. For those wanting four-door practicality without sacrificing excitement, the A3 warrants a close look.

  • Good gas mileage
  • Advanced features
  • Premium interior 

2. Nissan Altima

  • Average price: $25,500
  • Body style: Sedan
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good (2022 Top Safety Pick+)


The Nissan Altima impresses as a roomy, fuel-efficient sedan with available all-wheel drive and a starter-friendly price tag. Packed with Nissan's latest tech, it keeps new drivers safe with features like automatic emergency braking and blind spot warnings while also entertaining them through a sharp 8-inch dashboard display with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. Predicted to be a reliable daily driver, the Altima offers surprising get-up-and-go from its 2.5L 4-cylinder engine yet still nets up to 38 mpg on the highway. Between hi-tech safety shields and high value, the Altima delivers confidence and accessibility for navigating life in the driver’s seat.

  • Budget-friendly option
  • Good fuel efficiency
  • Reasonable cargo space
nissan altima
nissan altima

2. Nissan Altima

  • Average price: $25,500
  • Body style: Sedan
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good (2022 Top Safety Pick+)


The Nissan Altima impresses as a roomy, fuel-efficient sedan with available all-wheel drive and a starter-friendly price tag. Packed with Nissan's latest tech, it keeps new drivers safe with features like automatic emergency braking and blind spot warnings while also entertaining them through a sharp 8-inch dashboard display with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. Predicted to be a reliable daily driver, the Altima offers surprising get-up-and-go from its 2.5L 4-cylinder engine yet still nets up to 38 mpg on the highway. Between hi-tech safety shields and high value, the Altima delivers confidence and accessibility for navigating life in the driver’s seat.

  • Budget-friendly option
  • Good fuel efficiency
  • Reasonable cargo space

3. Volkswagen ID.4

  • Average price: $39,995
  • Body style: Electric SUV
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good (2021 Top Safety Pick)


Practicality meets sustainability in the Volkswagen ID.4. This electric SUV breaks the mold with a spacious yet sleek design ready for both daily errands and distance driving. Thanks to smart engineering, the ID.4 travels up to 260 miles between charging — plenty for family adventures near and far. The thoughtful interior prioritizes people over batteries, so passengers enjoy generous room to stretch out. Efficiency extends to the price tag too; starting under $39,995, the ID.4 makes EV ownership attainable for more buyers. Blending innovation with everyday usability, Volkswagen aims to electrify the journey, not complicate it.

  • Spacious interior 
  • Long range
  • Good safety rating
Volkswagen ID.4
Volkswagen ID.4

3. Volkswagen ID.4

  • Average price: $39,995
  • Body style: Electric SUV
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good (2021 Top Safety Pick)


Practicality meets sustainability in the Volkswagen ID.4. This electric SUV breaks the mold with a spacious yet sleek design ready for both daily errands and distance driving. Thanks to smart engineering, the ID.4 travels up to 260 miles between charging — plenty for family adventures near and far. The thoughtful interior prioritizes people over batteries, so passengers enjoy generous room to stretch out. Efficiency extends to the price tag too; starting under $39,995, the ID.4 makes EV ownership attainable for more buyers. Blending innovation with everyday usability, Volkswagen aims to electrify the journey, not complicate it.

  • Spacious interior 
  • Long range
  • Good safety rating

4. Buick Envision

  • Average price: $37,500
  • Body style: SUV
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good


For new drivers seeking an easy-handling SUV, the Buick Envision impresses with a refined ride belying its compact frame. Owners praise this handsome crossover for quality and reliability, while active safety features like blind spot monitoring cater to novice motorists. Inside, stay connected with available in-car Wi-Fi and let the smooth handling soak up miles effortlessly with Adaptive Cruise Control. Approachable size blended with premium touches make the Envision a sensible yet stylish intro to SUV ownership.

  • Many standard safety features
  • Good fuel-efficiency
  • Holds its resale value well
Buick Envision
Buick Envision

4. Buick Envision

  • Average price: $37,500
  • Body style: SUV
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good


For new drivers seeking an easy-handling SUV, the Buick Envision impresses with a refined ride belying its compact frame. Owners praise this handsome crossover for quality and reliability, while active safety features like blind spot monitoring cater to novice motorists. Inside, stay connected with available in-car Wi-Fi and let the smooth handling soak up miles effortlessly with Adaptive Cruise Control. Approachable size blended with premium touches make the Envision a sensible yet stylish intro to SUV ownership.

  • Many standard safety features
  • Good fuel-efficiency
  • Holds its resale value well

5. Nissan Sentra

  • Average price: $21,000
  • Body style: Sedan
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good apart from the headlights (the 2022 version was a Top Safety Pick+)


If you're looking for an easy-driving deal, you'll find a lot to like in the Nissan Sentra. Approachable size and nimble handling build confidence behind the wheel, while active safety shields watch for hazards in this value-packed sedan. Despite one of the most budget-friendly price tags in its segment, the Sentra still wraps drivers in protective tech usually reserved for premium models, including automated emergency braking, blind spot warnings, lane departure alerts, and more. Throw in excellent fuel economy, and the Sentra shapes up as the total package for new drivers on a budget.

  • Budget-friendly
  • Great fuel economy
  • Good reliability
Nissan Sentra
Nissan Sentra

5. Nissan Sentra

  • Average price: $21,000
  • Body style: Sedan
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good apart from the headlights (the 2022 version was a Top Safety Pick+)


If you're looking for an easy-driving deal, you'll find a lot to like in the Nissan Sentra. Approachable size and nimble handling build confidence behind the wheel, while active safety shields watch for hazards in this value-packed sedan. Despite one of the most budget-friendly price tags in its segment, the Sentra still wraps drivers in protective tech usually reserved for premium models, including automated emergency braking, blind spot warnings, lane departure alerts, and more. Throw in excellent fuel economy, and the Sentra shapes up as the total package for new drivers on a budget.

  • Budget-friendly
  • Great fuel economy
  • Good reliability

6. Tesla Model 3

  • Average price: $40,240
  • Body style: Sedan
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good (2021 Top Safety Pick)


In the Model 3, Tesla charges ahead on tech and performance fronts. Tap into instant acceleration and up to 358 miles of freedom between plug-ins. Touchscreens handle everything from navigation to infotainment system to climate, with over-the-air updates continuously expanding capabilities. New features roll out remotely along with fixes — no shop required. Combine gas savings with the value of advanced connectivity. For drivers craving innovation, the Model 3 sets the bar for both in-motion and in-garage thrills. 

  • Zero emissions 
  • Long range 
  • Continuous updates
Tesla Model 3
Tesla Model 3

6. Tesla Model 3

  • Average price: $40,240
  • Body style: Sedan
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good (2021 Top Safety Pick)


In the Model 3, Tesla charges ahead on tech and performance fronts. Tap into instant acceleration and up to 358 miles of freedom between plug-ins. Touchscreens handle everything from navigation to infotainment system to climate, with over-the-air updates continuously expanding capabilities. New features roll out remotely along with fixes — no shop required. Combine gas savings with the value of advanced connectivity. For drivers craving innovation, the Model 3 sets the bar for both in-motion and in-garage thrills. 

  • Zero emissions 
  • Long range 
  • Continuous updates

7. Volkswagen Golf GTI

  • Average price: $32,915
  • Body style: Sedan
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good (2022 Top Safety Pick)


The Volkswagen Golf GTI fuses sporty performance with hatchback flexibility. Its turbocharged engine pumps out 241 horsepower for an athletic yet efficient drive. Behind the wheel, the GTI feels well-balanced and eager to rev through corners. When it's time to haul cargo, the hatchback design expands practicality without sacrificing the fun factor. Starting under $33,000, the 2024 Golf GTI continues its legacy, blending power and practicality into one responsive package.

  • Sporty performance 
  • Fuel efficient 
  • Quality interior 
Volkswagen Golf GTI
Volkswagen Golf GTI

7. Volkswagen Golf GTI

  • Average price: $32,915
  • Body style: Sedan
  • Safety rating from IIHS: Good (2022 Top Safety Pick)


The Volkswagen Golf GTI fuses sporty performance with hatchback flexibility. Its turbocharged engine pumps out 241 horsepower for an athletic yet efficient drive. Behind the wheel, the GTI feels well-balanced and eager to rev through corners. When it's time to haul cargo, the hatchback design expands practicality without sacrificing the fun factor. Starting under $33,000, the 2024 Golf GTI continues its legacy, blending power and practicality into one responsive package.

  • Sporty performance 
  • Fuel efficient 
  • Quality interior 

How to choose the best first car for new drivers

Finding the best first car for new rivers can be challenging. Take a closer look at the following tips to help you make a better decision:

  • Consider the car's safety features: Safety should be a top priority when choosing a good first car. Look for vehicles with high safety ratings from organizations like the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS).
  • Prioritize reliability: A reliable car will require fewer repairs, saving you time, money, and stress. Brands like Honda, Toyota, Kia, Mazda, and Subaru are known for their reliability.
  • Keep the size in mind: Compact cars can be easier for new drivers to handle and park, but they should still offer sufficient interior space and comfort.
  • Check the cost of ownership: In addition to the purchase price, consider costs like fuel, insurance, maintenance, and depreciation. Some brands and models, such as Chevy or BMW, are more cost-effective to own than others.
  • Test drive before buying: A test drive can help you determine how comfortable and confident you feel behind the wheel of a particular car.
  • Consider buying used: Used cars can be of great value. Just make sure to have the vehicle inspected by a trusted mechanic before buying.
  • Research and shop around: Take the time to research different makes and models and compare prices from different dealerships. This can help you ensure that you're getting the best car for your needs at the best possible price.
  • Financing: Affordability is a major concern for most first-time car buyers. How are you going to finance the purchase, lease, or subscription? Sometimes, when buying a car, you may qualify for a pre-approved car loan that will tell you how much you can spend. Much depends on the length of the loan term you can negotiate, as well as the interest rates.


For drivers with no credit or limited credit (like many teens and younger drivers), options are more limited, but you can still get a car with no credit. Often, a more affordable option than buying a car is a subscription. With no down payment necessary, this saves around $2,000 for starters. You simply select a reliable car at an affordable monthly rate that includes everything.

What is an affordable first car?

Choosing an affordable first car involves weighing factors like price, safety, reliability, and cost of ownership. Here are a few models that often come up in discussions of affordable first cars:

  1. Honda Civic: Known for its reliability and fuel efficiency, the Honda Civic also offers advanced safety features. Its compact size makes it easy to handle for new drivers. As per recent search results, the 2024 Honda Civic starts at $23,950 for the base LX sedan model.
  2. Toyota Corolla: The Corolla has a long-standing reputation for reliability and durability. It's also known for excellent fuel economy and low-cost maintenance. The starting price for a new 2024 Toyota Corolla is approximately $20,025.
  3. Hyundai Elantra: This car offers good value for money with its comprehensive warranty, strong safety scores, and solid performance. The 2024 Hyundai Elantra starts at around $19,650.
  4. Ford Fiesta: This compact car is fun to drive and offers good fuel economy. But, the Ford Fiesta was discontinued in the U.S. after the 2019 model year and used models can be found for around $10,000 or less.
  5. Subaru Impreza: The Impreza stands out with standard all-wheel drive, good safety ratings, and a reputation for durability. The starting price for a new 2024 Subaru Impreza is approximately $18,795.
  6. Toyota Camry: A Camry is known for its low ownership costs, including reasonable maintenance expenses, making it an ideal choice for first-time buyers. The 2024 Toyota Camry starts at $26,420 for the base trim levels.

Car insurance for new drivers

For new and teen drivers, car insurance rates are typically higher than for middle-aged drivers. In fact, they can be up to three times more expensive. This is largely due to the perceived risk associated with inexperienced drivers. However, there are ways to navigate this and find reasonable rates.


One of the best strategies for lower insurance costs is to choose a car with good safety stats. Cars that are rated highly for safety by organizations such as the IIHS and NHTSA typically attract lower insurance premiums.


Shopping around for insurance deals is another good step. The cost of insurance varies significantly between providers, even for the same coverage levels. Geico, Nationwide, and Progressive are among the insurers offering the most competitive rates for young drivers. Also, companies like Allstate and State Farm have specific programs aimed at new and teen drivers.

Which car is best for a first-time driver?

The best car for a first-time driver depends on individual preferences, needs, and budget. If you're a first-time driver and you're looking for a car, consider safety, reliability, and affordability. Here are some top recommendations for first-time drivers:

  • Toyota Prius: This hybrid vehicle is not only eco-friendly but also boasts excellent safety features and reliability.
  • Nissan Versa: The Nissan Versa keeps costs low without skimping on safety. Its ample cabin and fuel-sipping engine combined with high reliability ratings make this sedan a sensible, secure choice for new drivers.
  • Subaru Crosstrek: Subaru Crosstrek stands out with its standard all-wheel drive, contributing to its strong safety scores.
  • Hyundai Kona: This compact SUV offers a comfortable ride and advanced safety features.
  • Volkswagen GolfGTI: A sporty option, the Golf GTI combines fun-to-drive characteristics with solid safety features.
  • Honda Accord: Regularly topping safety charts, the Honda Accord has long delivered reliability and value too. That combination of secure protection and low-fuss ownership makes this car an ideal fit for first-time drivers.
  • Mazda 3: For a first car, it's hard to top the Mazda 3's blend of value, protection, and just plain fun behind the wheel. This affordable package punches above its weight with nimble handling and zoomy responsiveness sure to make any new driver smile.
  • Chevrolet Cruze: This Chevrolet balances practicality and efficiency in a comfortable, compact package. With impressive fuel economy, abundant safety technology and a reasonable price, the Cruze easily carries new drivers in style.
  • Acura Integra: The Integra combines reliability and performance, making it a fun yet dependable choice for new drivers. Plus, with its solid build quality and affordable maintenance costs, it's great for those on a budget.


Once you've decided on the type of car you're interested in, consider a car subscription from FINN. Unlike traditional car ownership or leasing, FINN offers a flexible and hassle-free experience, with access to top car brands and models, without having to worry about insurance, maintenance, or roadside assistance, as these are all included in one monthly fee. There's also no need for a down payment, and the subscription terms are flexible, allowing you to switch to a new car every six to 12 months if you want. 

Final thoughts

The six cars listed are a great starting point to ensure that your first car is safe, reliable, and affordable. Many of them also have enviable driving experiences and the looks to match. 


If you want to avoid many of the hassles and extra expenses that come with buying a car, you may want to consider a car subscription from FINN. Select your preferred model then drive care-free with insurance, maintenance, and roadside assistance bundled into one monthly fee. No money down, no contracts. And the flexibility to switch vehicles every six to 12 months lets you find the right fit now with the freedom to explore what's next.

best first cars
best first cars

Final thoughts

The six cars listed are a great starting point to ensure that your first car is safe, reliable, and affordable. Many of them also have enviable driving experiences and the looks to match. 


If you want to avoid many of the hassles and extra expenses that come with buying a car, you may want to consider a car subscription from FINN. Select your preferred model then drive care-free with insurance, maintenance, and roadside assistance bundled into one monthly fee. No money down, no contracts. And the flexibility to switch vehicles every six to 12 months lets you find the right fit now with the freedom to explore what's next.

You may also like

Are Audis Reliable?

Are Audis Reliable?

Dive into the world of Audi and learn about their reliability, cutting-edge technology, maintenance needs, and unparalleled driving experience.

Read more
Are Cadillacs Reliable Cars?

Are Cadillacs Reliable Cars?

Cadillacs have been renowned for style and luxury since the early 1900s but how reliable are they? Find out how Cadillacs stack up for dependability.

Read more
Are Nissans Reliable Cars?

Are Nissans Reliable Cars?

Are Nissans reliable cars? Learn more about Nissan's reliability, including what models you should avoid to reduce your maintenance costs.

Read more